Independent guide152 NYC haulers reviewedUpdated June 2026
Best Junk Removal NYC
Home / Directory / Mr. T Carting

Mr. T Carting reviews

3.1 (75 reviews · Google)
Licensed & insured$$$$$

Review summary

Mr. T Carting is a family-owned NYC carting and dumpster-rental company (since 1947) whose reviews are sharply split: one-off residential dumpster and clean-out customers rate it highly (4.7 on HomeTownDumpsterRental) for on-time, friendly, tidy service, while recurring commercial-pickup customers drag its Google rating to about 3.0-3.1 over missed pickups, rude staff, and surprise charges. It holds an A+ (non-accredited) BBB rating.

👍 Pros
  • Reliable long-term service for one-off dumpster rentals and clean-outs
  • On-time delivery and pickup, area left clean
  • Friendly, courteous crews
  • Competitive rates / good value
👎 Cons
  • Missed or skipped recurring commercial pickups (weeks without service)
  • Unprofessional or rude staff and poor call-back responsiveness
  • Surprise overweight/extra-tonnage charges

What customers say

“I needed a trash pick-up for an event that we had for leftover food and other debris... They came on time and hauled away everything, keeping the area clean.”— Patrice A. · 5★, HomeTownDumpsterRental ↗
“I contracted Mr. T Carting for a basement clean out... They hauled away two 15 yard containers... They did the job quickly and they were friendly guys.”— W. (Brooklyn) · 5★, HomeTownDumpsterRental ↗
“We were doing some renovation and needed a 10 yard dumpster for construction debris... They were wonderful to work with.”— Theresa S. · 5★, HomeTownDumpsterRental ↗
“I needed a dumpster rental... mostly sheetrock... they were excellent... Everything went smoothly.”— Vandike W. · 5★, HomeTownDumpsterRental ↗
“Horrible, horrible, horrible! I regret choosing this company for my restaurant. This garbage company works like garbage. It's been 3 weeks that we didn't receive the service and the agents are extremely unprofessional and rude. Just disgusting.”— Anjela Sahibzada · 1★, Google (via Birdeye) ↗
“The absolute worst and that's saying a lot. Limited pickup times of they show up at all and impossible to get them to come back when they 'miss' a pickup. Numerous calls no call backs. Stay away if in nyc area.”— Josh Cohen · 1★, Google (via Birdeye) ↗

Compare with our top pick

Prefer upfront online pricing and same-day booking? JunkRabbit quotes you in about a minute.

Get an instant price →